SHARE:

HOW DOES THE COURT DECIDE ON THE AMOUNT OF MAINTENANCE FOR EX-WIFE?

Section 114(1) of the Women’s Charter provides some guidance in the form of a non-exhaustive list of factors that the Court will consider.

maintenance of ex wife

 .

HOW DOES THE COURT DECIDE ON THE AMOUNT OF MAINTENANCE FOR EX-WIFE?

.

This article will briefly cover three areas regarding an ex-wife’s maintenance:

  1. Determining the amount
  2. Nominal maintenance
  3. Variation of maintenance

     .

How does the Court determine the amount of maintenance for ex-wife?

The Court looks at a variety of factors when making a maintenance order.  There is no definite formula.  Nevertheless, section 114(1) of the Women’s Charter provides some guidance in the form of a non-exhaustive list of factors that the Court will consider.  Some of the factors include:

  1. Earning capacity of the parties;
  2. Assets of the parties;
  3. Financial needs of the parties;
  4. Age of each party; and
  5. Standard of living of the parties before the divorce.

In considering the factors above, the main principle that guides the Court is that of financial preservation. This means that the Court will, as much as it is possible, maintain the parties in the financial position as it was during the marriage before the breakdown.

The Courts recognize that it may not be possible to maintain such a possible. In Foo Ah Yan v Chiam Heng Chow [2012] SGCA 15, the courts held that the principle of financial preservation should be applied in a commonsense holistic manner. This means that while the Court acknowledges that the husband should maintain the ex-wife, it would nevertheless take into account the breakdown of the marriage. Ultimately, the Court is of the opinion that the ex-wife should not expect a full subsidy and should have some effort in preserving her lifestyle prior to the divorce.

Having said that, the Court would also consider the husband’s ability to meet the maintenance order and balance it against the ex-wife’s claim.

 .

What does “no order as to maintenance” mean?

The usual order to preserve an ex-wife’s right to maintenance is to make one for nominal maintenance. In other words, the Court will award the wife a maintenance of $1 per month to protect her right such that she would be able to vary the amount in the future.

However, The Court of Appeal have recently in 2015 saw the need to affirm the position regarding an order for nominal maintenance again. In APE v APF [2015] SGCA 47, the Court clarified that making no order as to maintenance is an outright rejection for the of a wife’s application for maintenance. This means that the ex-wife would not be allowed to apply for maintenance when such an order is given. The correct order to make is therefore the original position, that an order for nominal maintenance should be made to preserve the ex-wife’s right.

 .

What will the Court consider in a variation of maintenance order?

To vary a maintenance order, the applicant must show that there was a mistake of fact, misrepresentation and/or material change in circumstances. In this article, we will focus at what is constitutes a material change in circumstances.

To apply for a downward adjustment of maintenance, the material change must be an adverse change. For example, the husband might find it difficult to meet the payment due to illness or unemployment. It must be noted here that the adverse change must not be self-induced.

In the ex-wife’s case, to apply for an upward adjustment, the needs of the wife would be balanced with the ex-husband’s ability to pay. Some examples may include a significant increase in the ex-husband’s income or perhaps a sudden windfall.

 . .

ABOUT PKWA FAMILY LAW

singapore family lawyers

At PKWA Law, our team of Family Lawyers are consistently named as leading Singapore family lawyers by respected independent legal publications such as Asian Legal Business, Singapore Business Review, Global Law Experts and Doyle’s Guide to Singapore Family Lawyers. 

Contact us at tel 6854-5336 for a free first consultation. 

 .

RELATED ARTICLES:

Singapore Divorce Lawyer .

Keen to discuss more? Contact PKWA Law today for your free consultation.
Call Us At +65 6854 5336
(Family Law)
Call Us At +65 6397 6100
(Conveyancing)
Email Us At mail@pkwalaw.com